Defending DNA?

The infallibility of DNA is in question after Israeli researchers discover the genetic code can be forged.
The infallibility of DNA is in question after Israeli researchers discover the genetic code can be forged.

Scientists: DNA Evidence Can Be Fabricated

Observing the use of DNA evidence in the judicial system during the past 20 years has been exciting for this forensics nerd. The potential for further analysis to narrow an individual’s genome code and separate it from other suspects has grown exponentially. The judicial system has experienced what you might call growing pains–several states have called moratoriums on death penalty cases, while other states have had case reviews if DNA is present but was not eligible for testing when the case was first tried in court. What has since come to pass is a number of people have been exonerated–cleared of the crime they were convicted of–due to the introduction of DNA evidence. In other cases, some individuals remain incarcerated because the DNA proved that person’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Or so we thought.

So now what is our less-than-stellar justice system supposed to do since a group of Israeli researchers have reported that DNA can be fabricated? Where does that leave us? I realize that the average criminal isn’t going to bother going to all of the trouble to plant someone else’s DNA at a crime scene, but anything is possible in these troubled times. Our country was making strides in improving the weaknesses in our justice system, yet now we have to defend the one piece of evidence that we wholeheartedly (or rather foolheartedly) believed in, thanks to TV shows like CSI, Forensic Files, Dateline, and 48 Hours Mystery. This new finding brings up so many unanswered questions. Have we been wrong about DNA all along?

5 thoughts on “Defending DNA?

    1. Frightening, isn’t it? What does LC have to say about it? I’m surprised that there hasn’t been more of an outcry over this. Could it be bogus? Or does DNA not play that big a role in solving crimes? We just think it does because of the influence of the media. Hmm…

  1. Paula

    What about healthcare workers who have access to blood, sperm, etc. It would be easy to collect the DNA of a known criminal or a person who could be considered a suspect then plant that individuals DNA at a crime scene. I can only imagine it has already happened.

    1. Prior to writing this article I would not think that was possible, but now I’m not so sure. This new study provides reasonable doubt for defendants who claim that DNA evidence in their cases was planted.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s